Published July 21, 2023, 7:20 a.m. by Monica Louis
AGNES VARDA: FROM HERE TO THERE is now streaming on MUBI (almost) globally. Get one month free: https://mubi.com/cinemacartography
0:00 Introduction (Ashes and Snow, A Time to Live A Time to Die, Strangers In Good Company, Borom Sarat, Dead Man's Letter's, Killer of Sheep, Napoleon, Still Life)
1:50 The Fifth Seal - Az ötödik pecsét (Dir: Zoltán Fábri)
7:29 The House Is Black - خانه سیاه است (Dir: Forough Farrokhzad)
9:57 Tie Xi Qu: West of The Tracks - 铁西区 (Dir: Wang Bing)
14:12 As I Was Moving Ahead Occasionally I Saw Brief Glimpses of Beauty (Dir: Jonas Mekas)
18:37 The Enclosed Valley - La vallée close (Dir: Jean-Claude Rousseau)
19:37 Pastoral: To Die in the Country - 田園に死す (Dir: Shūji Terayama)
28:03 The cremator - Spalovač mrtvol (Dir: Juraj Herz)
30:28 O Pagador de Promessas (Dir: Anselmo Duarte)
31:39 Conclusion (lucifer rising, An Elephant Sitting Still, Marketa Lazarova, White Noise, Platform, The Burmese Harp)
Support this project and get involved on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/cinemacartography
For business inquiries: contact@thecinemacartography.com
You may also like to read about:
welcome to the cinema cartography
[Music]
when we speak of the cinematic canon
there's an ingrained knowledge of what
films make up cinema with a capital c
even those we may not have had direct
familiarization with will be embedded in
our minds by the collective
consciousness of art and its history
its fundamental knowledge and in many
ways indisputable
but knowledge can be lost
and that which should have been part of
our cinema now wanders somewhere in the
ether
this is not an attempt to capture the
most obscure films that people haven't
seen nor is it an attempt to bring to
light films that do not deserve
recognition
this is an attempt to bring awareness to
those films that for one reason or
another have been excluded from the
conversation of cinema's greatest
triumphs
these are not just worthwhile films to
see
these are the instances of forgotten
films which truly belong within the
highest echelon that the art has to
offer
this is a celebration of cinema and
although you may be aware of some of
these works this is not enough for it's
my hope that these films gain the status
that they deserve as some of the
greatest films ever created
this video is brought to you by mubi a
curated streaming service showing
exceptional films from around the globe
try movie free for 30 days at movie.com
cinema cartography that's mubi.com
cinema cartography for a whole month of
great cinema for free
philosophical cinema can be traced back
to the earliest days of cinema when
filmmakers such as lewis manuel
attempted to narrativize through
abstraction marrying the moving image
with poetry of thought
not only did this make him an integral
figure in the surrealist movement he
made the approach of philosophy and
cinema subversive
philosophy could be intertwined
discussed and developed within cinema
and bergman making the seventh seal on
wild strawberries in 1957 raw art house
philosophical cinema widespread
attention
the idea of a literal discussion of
pre-existing philosophies through cinema
was an idea that expanded all the way up
until the 1981 masterpiece my dinner
with andre wonderful shape
i mean they were literally driving my
father crazy you know here's an 82 year
old man who's very emotional and you
know if you go in one moment and you see
the person's dying and you don't want
them to die and then a doctor comes out
five minutes later and tells you that
wonderful shape i mean you know you can
go crazy
in which the entirety of the film is a
conversation of two friends meeting and
discussing what's essentially the
entirety of human existence
almost antithetical to the cinematic
experience my dinner with andre doesn't
need to show because it's all tell yet
there is a film that came before this
that i believe to have reached the
zenith of philosophical discussion in
cinema
zoltan fabies the fifth seal
similar to my dinner with andre the
fifth seal is primarily focused around a
philosophical discussion a group of men
in world war ii hungary gather in a bar
and have a diverging conversation it
isn't until one of the men asks a single
question that the axis of the film is
completely altered and it's on this
swaying pendulum that the film remains
until its end
time
would we choose to be born as a tyrant
that punishes and tortures his subjects
yet never feels remorse in his actions
or would we choose to be born as a slave
who undergo subjugation each day yet can
take solace in the fact that they harbor
no evil within them the film is composed
of three acts it begins in an inn where
the characters engage in their
discussion then a brief respite in the
evening when the characters return home
and the finale is held in the
headquarters of the hungarian party
allied with the nazis
here at
each segment of the film is shot in
completely enclosed spaces as once the
seminal question has been uttered
there's no escape from the line of
thought that the film has made subject
and become subjected to
the film is the question and it's able
to take this philosophizing to its most
extreme level examining the futility of
human behavior under extreme
circumstances
rather than just relying on the
discussion to convey its point the fifth
seal expounds its ideas on a theoretical
basis as much as it's possibly capable
of doing only to move away from the
theoretical to the experience
of
the second act serves almost like an
interlude we have the opportunity to
weigh the moralities of our characters
via a brief glimpse into their personal
lives
some doing incredibly righteous things
while others doing less so
and it's during this sequence that we
begin to acknowledge that the world
depicted isn't precisely one of
actuality the film extrapolates the
truth of a most extreme situation to the
point it becomes allegory
[Music]
the filmmaking resembles that of a play
to display the veracity of a point of
view unencumbered by any filmic
furnishings
when we're constantly addressed with the
question the film is as flat as it can
be it's important that the film makes
its points directly
hammering in our head the responsibility
we have in precarious times by simply
showing us the suffering that we or
others will endure
the fifth seal shows us the importance
of making decisions
when we're simultaneously
helpless in making one
let's get to his cases i guess
documentary is a difficult enough genre
to entice audiences to engage with from
the get-go
it's rare that a documentary becomes a
cultural phenomenon equal to that of
narrative film
all that's brought to mind are the likes
of supersize me and fahrenheit 911
because even for ardent cinema goers it
can be surprisingly rare to find one
that's willing to go to the cinema with
the intention of watching a documentary
perhaps being so close to real life is
the demeaning factor that even within
the art of cinema people are still
hoping for some degree of escapism
ironic that as many good documentaries
aim to expose the forgotten parts of the
world they themselves become forgotten
the iranian poet photo faroxad's
landmark documentary short the house is
black transports us to a place we
wouldn't even dare to tread
a leper colony
taking those directly within the worlds
of these people it's shot with a sublime
poetic quality that both captures the
tragedy of this world yet elevates these
people to treat them with utmost respect
my
this is a world that we aim to forget
but farooq zad uses the documentary
medium as her tool of immortalizing this
world so that no matter how hard we aim
to avoid it it may persist longer than
we
our role becoming either that of someone
who fought for justice for the outcasts
of this world or one that allowed them
to be such
the house is black is a harrowing
experience displaying the horror of
human decay with the beauty of human
creation and like all great
documentaries it encapsulates the good
and the bad of the human condition
balancing the realism and the magic of
cinema
but even stories that are tied to a
certain time or culture still in one way
or another are connected to these
universal human stories
yet one documentary filmmaker whose
entire filmography is entrenched in the
politics of his homeland is wang bing
wang bing's work is a memento a way of
honoring the legacy of the chinese
people in both their history and their
strife
focusing primarily on the political
fallout of china in the 20th century his
works are epic ventures into the
cataclysmic effects on the world's
largest population yet he translates
these sentiments through focusing on the
smallest of gestures
his seminal work taishiku west of the
tracks is a nine hour piece examining
china's economic shift from complete
state control into a free market society
and the effect this has had on its
forgotten workers
[Music]
foreign
[Music]
high cq over the course of around two
and a half years and when did that time
he had the patience to capture on film a
paradigm shift the beginning of one new
world and the slow death of another his
use of extreme long takes with his
observational approach allows taishiku
to capture the scale and breadth of the
circumstances while also honing in on
how a geopolitical shift affects
families in their day-to-day activities
the work of wang bing in many ways are
all companion pieces to one another many
of his documentaries being over five
hours in length they attempt to shed
light on one of the most misunderstood
and constantly shifting cultures in the
world
a common thematic motif of bing is
exposing the remnants of the once maui
society and its attempts to ingratiate
itself within a modernized world while
at the same time attempting to lead it
bing's work has a sense that there is no
intrusion on the part of the filmmaker
that what's captured is the purest in
very similar tude to the real experience
yet this in itself is an artistic choice
aimed to highlight what's in front of us
a subtle way of asking us to pay closer
attention to what's really occurring
his piece feng ming a chinese memoir is
essentially a three-hour interview of a
woman discussing her time in the labor
camps on the mao
wang bing wants to capture in
documentary the grand and most recent
history in china's darkest chapters
yet at the same time always prioritizing
to condense the entirety of that history
to view how it fits into the story of a
humble individual
the self will always be a cornerstone of
artistic exploration for many they're
interested in the kaleidoscopic
interactions of people
for others the artist may inevitably
turn to their own self for deep
introspective explorations a la
fellini's eight and a half
however perhaps the ultimate cathartic
exploration into the artist's own story
is found in the work of jonas marcus
his magnum opus as i was moving ahead
occasionally i saw brief glimpses of
beauty can also be called a documentary
yet in truth it's closer to a
compilation work
the ecstasy of filming
just
filming life
around me
what i see
to what i react
to what my fingers my eyes react this
moment now
this moment when it's all happening
ah
what ecstasy
made at the age of 77 marcus compiled
together footage from his old home
movies in an attempt to reconstruct his
life the film footage we see spans over
the course of decades we watch marcus
grow from a young man into a father his
family members that have long passed and
every insignificant moment that in this
newfound context gathers an incredibly
beautiful meaning
for as we watch the film meccus watches
along with us speaking to us
i'm talking to you now
una
and sebastian
and hollis
i'm talking to you
now
[Music]
these are
my
memories
your memories of the same
[Music]
moment
if you will have any
you'll be very
different
this is how life was captured and how it
appeared through the eyes of meccas
now he's taking that footage with even
more context and reflection
this is a man's life curated by himself
for hair towards the final stages of his
life in his moments of deepest
reflection he sees not regret
all that's left is beauty
not beauty of any overwhelming kind but
the quiet understanding of those
fleeting tranquil moments in which so
much of life is made
ah my friends
the hours the evenings we spent together
that was
paradise
as time goes
as time goes
there is nothing more important
than good
friends
my friends
in the end we only have our memories
our memories are a completely new life
within themselves
his other diary films walden and
reminiscences of a journey to lithuania
are equally ethereal and beautiful
contemplations into trying to make sense
of one's life but finding oneself
content and being lost in the beauty
i do not
know how i managed to reach this point
how i have
reached this
point in my
life
but i continue moving ahead
slowly
moving ahead
and some glimpses of happiness and
beauty
come
my way
by chance
when i do not even expect it
comparisons to mecca's diary films can
also be found in jean-claude clauseau's
le faleclos in which rousseau takes
blocks of image from super 8 and with an
approach reminiscent to that of the
soviet masters
allows the relation of the images
between one another to denote their
meaning
rather than with intrusion
this is purest experimentation
the editing exercise being that if we
leave a film as it is and allow it to
construct itself what are the results
that will emerge
there's a humility in shooting in such
simple means however the valley close is
one of the more daring experiments with
the moving image and similar to the work
of meccas it's the serendipity of what's
captured that was unintended wherein
deep rooted magic is to be found
there's no dialogue no movement
just pure sensation
for it's one thing to birth an idea
within one's mind and it's another to
translate that for the artist can often
be the biggest boundary in the way of
their own ideas and similar again to how
fellini approached amacord we can view
suji terayama's pastoral to die in the
country
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
at first what may appear to be japanese
surrealist work stretched out to the
highest levels of absurdity after a
prolonged setting into its bizarre logic
we begin to be able to find some sense
of deep metaphor within the film's
layers of symbology even if they feel
loose and disconnected
[Music]
now it would be appropriate to describe
what kind of narrative that a film as
surreal as pastoral is attempting to
convey however
this may be to the film's detriment
for it's only until almost halfway
through the film that the war between us
and the world of pastoral is shattered
and we begin to realize just what kind
of adventure we're in for
[Music]
pastoral to die in the country is
terrayama's take on subconscious
filmmaking
with all of its incredible compositions
over-the-top costumes and sets and
filmmaking techniques that appear
intentionally misplaced it would be
ignorant to disregard the technical
prowess of pastoral as just an excuse to
make surrealist images solely for
aesthetic grandeur this is a
sentimentality
the likes of which are present in the
dance of reality
if pastoral is the director's means of
remembering his past then up to what
point are they not truthful
if anything this is the only document
that exists of such a life
sequences within pastoral are so
personal to the filmmaker himself that
it seems strange to say
but this is the only rational way these
memories could be expressed
[Music]
they're exclusively his they have no
necessity to belong within the real
world the film allows these differing
modes of reality to blur within the
image
the reality of the film collapsing is
paradoxically the method in which it can
establish itself as artistic truth
the artist can be seen as the final
obstacle a piece must overcome for it to
reach its zenith but of course it's seen
as that for perhaps the best lessons on
the artist ingratiating themselves
within the work were in these seldom
spoke-off masterpieces
sometimes a work is forgotten because it
too closely resembles the uncomfortable
truths of the current state of the world
a film like sallow was so provocative in
its depiction of european fascism that
it's been etched in the annals of
cinematic history however a film that
predates sallow that's so true to life
we don't want to believe it to be so is
peter watkins's punishment park
if it's up to you kind of people we
would just shut down these factories
we'd burn them down we'd all go out and
panhandle in the street then what kind
of society would we have then
what kind of how would you how would you
feed people then
so you want us to work and support you
that's what you want
there's enough food enough wealth in
this country to take care of everyone in
this country if everybody there is
everyone around the
or to go around the streets and have
orgies all the time and sleep in the
streets i'm going around the streets
having orgies all the time you're not
huh burning down buildings i'm concerned
as you are about the direction of this
country
filmed as a fake documentary the
performances and structure may have you
believe that it's anything but
this is a film about the manner in which
the real world operates on the regimes
of control as a result authenticity is
one of the major ingredients of time
dismissal on what grounds constitutional
in particular first fourth fifth and
fourteenth amendment motion overruled
the [ __ ] you gonna overrule the
constitution
keep the defendant silent
and if it please the court i'd like to
introduce a motion to have each of the
defendant's convictions reviewed
separately what king's aim is to prod
you don't for one second think that just
because this is fiction that it isn't
happening right now and that precarious
barrier between the real world and the
film is one that's often questioned we
use force against them we will not take
any chances with these individuals
they've killed once i don't like to lose
men
did any of you know the deputy that was
killed
quite the opposite we're not doing this
for ourselves we're doing this for the
people who pay the taxes
watkins's approach is that of an
intensely provocative touch the
cinematic style is simple as that it
doesn't become distracting
thereby watching the piece
every infuriating twist of the knife
from those that abuse power can be felt
what punishment park is is the place
that people elect to go to so that they
don't have to go to a penitentiary to
serve a sentence for what's essentially
a baseless accusation on their statuses
as criminals
all they have to do is obey the rules
and finish the tasks set ahead of them
the object of this course is simple
you must evade capture by the pursuing
law enforcement officers and reach the
flag by the appointed time
that is to say 10 o'clock on the evening
the third day from now
yet in an enraging turn of events we
watch how no matter what our
protagonists do
they're not in control of the rules of
their circumstances
almost as if they can't win because the
game itself is rigged
punishment park opens with a meekly
blowing american flag in the distance
and its transgression of the documentary
genre never lets us forget that this is
a film about americans
all of them
famously the same year as punishment
park was the stamford prison experiment
in which normal people found themselves
as power-hungry maniacs ready to dish
out torture and humiliation onto others
but if the idea of a tyrannical force
ready to suppress any descent seems a
bit too hyperbolic due to its
controversial content punishment park
was denied distribution by all major
studios
a politician is nothing but a debater
all that you do is debate issues you fat
pig you meathead that's all that you are
because you are you are a flying sucker
you lying to the camera you lying to
your mama you lying to everybody but
every time you open up your mouth all
right
you know cause you ain't got no humanity
in
it's rare to grant a film the status of
ahead of its time yet punishment park
could be viewed as a film that paved the
way for the found footage genre
particularly combined with the lens of
intense violence
however another that would slot into the
space of any new wave magnum opus is uri
herze's the cremator
[Music]
[Music]
much like punishment park the cremator
is an altogether unresting experience
yet rather than approaching the descent
into maddening behavior at the
sociological level we examine it from a
single deluded individual
one of the entries in a prominent czech
new wave the superb black and white
cinematography shot by stanislav milota
shot the film primarily in wide lenses
to give the shots of coffin-filled rooms
an overwhelming feeling
[Music]
the constant manipulation from behind
the camera unnerves and unsettles the
viewer to the point that they want to
completely reject the ugliness of this
film's main character the cremator
follows cattle a worker in a crematorium
who under the radicalization of europe
in the second world war devolves from a
well-intentioned man to a mass murderer
complicit in the genocide of
extermination camps the cremator is not
just a fascinating story of one man's
plunge into darkness it's an expertly
crafted piece of cinema taking editing
inspiration from yan svankmaya and even
the writings of satra we see glimpses of
hieronymus bosch and the stylistic
parallels to bunwell the cremator is
what's now referred to as a cult classic
yet it is in fact cinema of the highest
caliber
[Music]
and although we've seen films that were
bypassed or negated from their initial
release
this is not true with all of these
forgotten pieces
for example opagadoji promises by
ensemoduachi
is not only a masterpiece of brazilian
cinema it was the recipient of the 1962
palme d'or following a humble land owner
opagadoji promesis tells the story of
his donkey approaching death but the man
promises that if he survives then he
shall carry a cross on his back across
the country and offer the cross to a
priest bringing with it the expected
magic realist tones we expect from south
american cinema opaga doji promesus was
a landmark film appearing to even have
some influence on oazad balthazar a
still recognized milestone in cinema and
some oduachi's adaptation is solemn and
inspiring dealing with issues of faith
and sacrifice through beautifully
interwoven poetry
some parts near realist some parts
allegorical a rightfully celebrated work
of genius upon its release
so where did all that acclaim go
why did these films in the canon of
cinema
disappear
because knowledge is something that we
must maintain
we are the keepers of what tomorrow's
future will be
and if we don't decide to uphold the
bastions of our culture then it will be
decided for us
some films have not had enough time for
them to be recognized antoine de gato's
white noise has portrayed the depths of
the human experience through nothing
more than monologues and grim fragmented
cinematography jiashanki has become a
more renowned filmmaker yet his work
platform has yet to be recognized as
what it truly is one of the seminal
works of the century
other films suffered different fates
kon ichikawa's 1956 to burmese harp was
one of the most important japanese films
to date examining the effects of the
second world war from the perspective of
their own army yet the story only gained
the audience recognition it deserved
when it was remade in colour 30 years
later
some films are ahead of their time
audiences not ready to be exposed to
them others are just unfortunate but
regardless of what mistakes were made in
the role of film watchers
it's never too late to bring lost
greatness to the world
for great cinema will always be great
and it's our duty to ensure that it
remains as such
[Music]
we'd like to thank mubi for sponsoring
this video mubi is a curated streaming
service an ever-changing collection of
handpicked films from new directors to
award winners from everywhere on earth
beautiful interesting incredible movies
and always carefully chosen by movie
curators you can stream or download all
of movies movies anytime on any screen
any device anywhere
right now movie you can watch agnes
varda from her to there with her
subversive take on documentary from here
to there follows varda over a two-year
period and serves as her travelogue as
she travels all around the world we get
to watch her reflect and contemplate on
all things from art food and friends
mubi is the perfect gateway to world
cinema and the only streaming platform
the cinema cartography fully recommends
you can try mubi for free for 30 days at
mubi.com cinema cartography for a whole
month of great cinema for free
[Music]
you
2CUTURL
Created in 2013, 2CUTURL has been on the forefront of entertainment and breaking news. Our editorial staff delivers high quality articles, video, documentary and live along with multi-platform content.
© 2CUTURL. All Rights Reserved.